Feud between selmy and be ioff free#

I started out really liking Barristan the Bold.

'May the Warrior protect us all,' he told his lads. There was nothing like the prospect of death to make a man feel alive. Barristan Selmy slipped it down over his head, fastened it to his gorget, pulled up his shield, slipped his arm inside the straps. The chapter closes with another badass quote. You may cry out for your mother, pray to gods you thought you had forgotten, howl obscenities that you never dreamed could pass your lips. You may drop your sword, your shield, your lance.

Nothing is more terrible upon this earth, nothing more glorious, nothing more absurd. I am an old man, an old knight, and I have seen more battles than most of you have years. Read it for yourself, but speaking personally, I think it's an awesome harbinger of great things to come in The Winds of Winter. Barristan Selmy gives an epic speech to his soldiers about to fight the Slaver Army outside of Meereen. They're from Barristan's sample chapter in the paperback edition of ADWD. So, there's two last Barristan quotes I wanted to add. Two Final Barristan Quotes From the Sample Chapter in The Winds of Winter What will Barristan's role be in The Winds of Winter and beyond? Will Barristan survive the Battle of Fire? What information might Barristan be hiding? Should Barristan have been banished along with Jorah for his deception of Daenerys? Why or why not?īarristan has a habit of telling stories to Dany and then cutting the stories off before he hits a controversial point. Speaking personally, when I read the books, I had no idea who Arstan Whitebeard was until his reveal in ASOS. Why did Barristan choose Daenerys over Stannis or Renly when he was stripped of his white cloak by Joffrey? Also, if you have suggestions for better questions, please don't hesitate to suggest them in the comments section!ĭid Barristan Selmy violate his oath by serving Robert Baratheon after Aerys II Targaryen died? If he did violate his oath, do you think he was morally justified in some way?ĭid Barristan know about Aerys II's rape of Rhaella Targaryen and other atrocities committed by Aerys II? These are intended to spur discussion, and the users of r/asoiaf shouldn't feel compelled to answer them if they don't wish to.

Feud between selmy and be ioff free#

Robert pardoned Barristan and Jaime, and they accepted the pardon and continued to serve.įeel free to answer these question or write your own impressions and thoughts on Barristan Selmy. The oaths did not envision rebellion, actually. A good witness? Well, there were things he was not privy to, and of course he saw events from his own standpoint.ĭoes the oath of a Kingsguard include to serve whoever is the king, even if the new king rebelled against the old one, or did Jaime and Barristan choose to continue their service as Robert was crowned? Is Barristan, for his personality and for being a member of the Kingsguard and keeping the king's secrets, a good witness about Varys influence over Aerys?Ī witness, certainly. On Barristan as a witness to Varys' Activities The fact is, Kings are more likely to trust the Kingsguard and their loyalty than the High Lords who will be looking out for themselves. Is this a normal happening or a rarity?Īnswer: It has happened quite a bit throughout history. Specifically, Prince Lewyn, Jon Darry, and Barristan Selmy in the War of the Usurper and Selmy again in the Balon Greyjoy rebellion. It is noted on occasion that members of the Kingsguard have led armies. On why Barristan and other kingsguard led the King's armies

If both men had equivalent weaponry, it might be a toss-up. Who would win in a fight, Barristan Selmy or Arthur Dayne (in their best days)?ĭayne. George RR Martin on who would win in a fight between Barristan Selmy and Arthur Dayne